Ajit Doval: The Myth vs. The Truth — A Fact-Check for Modi Bhakts

Ajit Doval, India’s National Security Advisor (NSA) since 2014, has earned a reputation as one of the most influential and mysterious figures in India’s security establishment. But how much of the dramatic narrative shared in pro-government or Modi bhakt circles is true, and how much is myth-making or exaggeration?

Let’s break this down carefully, point by point, and separate the facts from the fiction.

🌄 Background: Who Is Ajit Doval?

✅ TRUE

• Born in 1945 in Pauri Garhwal, Uttarakhand.
• Joined the Indian Police Service (IPS) in 1968, Kerala cadre.
• Served as an intelligence officer for decades, notably in the Intelligence Bureau (IB), rising to Director of IB in 2004.
• Appointed National Security Advisor by Narendra Modi in 2014, continuing through to today.

This much is well-documented and verifiable.

🕶 Claim 1: Spent 7 Years as a Maulana in Lahore

⚠ PARTLY TRUE / EXAGGERATED
There is no official, declassified record that confirms Doval personally lived undercover in Lahore disguised as a Maulana for seven years.
✔ It’s known he operated in Pakistan and was involved in intelligence gathering, but the “seven years in disguise” is a popular folklore narrative often repeated without hard evidence. Intelligence missions are classified, and such exact details tend to be dramatized.

🔫 Claim 2: Entered Golden Temple During Black Thunder

✅ TRUE (as per reports)
During Operation Black Thunder (1988) to flush out militants from the Golden Temple, Doval reportedly went inside disguised as an ISI agent and gathered vital intelligence, helping reduce bloodshed compared to the disastrous Operation Blue Star.
This is one of the better-documented parts of his career.

💣 Claim 3: Turned Militants Against Militants in Kashmir

✅ TRUE
Doval was known for psychological operations in Kashmir, where rather than only capturing militants, some were convinced or manipulated to turn against rival groups.
This is a documented strategy in counterinsurgency, and Doval is credited with effectively using it.

✈ Claim 4: Negotiated With the Taliban in Kandahar (1999 Hijacking)

✅ TRUE
Doval was part of the Indian negotiating team during the Indian Airlines Flight IC-814 hijacking in Kandahar.
However, remember — India had to release terrorists (including Maulana Masood Azhar) to save hostages, which many saw as a forced, humiliating compromise.

⚔ Claim 5: Crossed Borders for Surgical Strikes in Myanmar

⚠ PARTLY TRUE / EXAGGERATED
India’s 2015 cross-border operation targeting NSCN-K militants in Myanmar was a military decision executed by the army, with inputs from NSA Doval.
The romantic idea that Doval himself “crossed the border” personally is overblown — he coordinated from the top, not on the ground like Rambo.

🕸 Claim 6: Befriended or Absorbed Networks Like Taliban, TTP, Al-Qaeda

❌ MOSTLY FALSE / DRAMATIZED
India does not run or absorb groups like the Taliban or Al-Qaeda — in fact, it maintains them as major security threats.
This is pure exaggeration. While intelligence networks may gather informants or assets, it is misleading to claim India has co-opted such global terror groups.

🗺 Claim 7: Silent After Pahalgam Because He’s Planning a Deadly Rewrite of Pakistan’s Map

⚠ PURE SPECULATION / POLITICAL FANTASY
No evidence supports that Doval or the Indian government is planning to redraw Pakistan’s borders or orchestrate some massive hidden military strike.
Security experts note that while India responds firmly to terror attacks, open wars or large-scale operations are rarely planned silently without any strategic leaks, troop movements, or international signals.
This is political fan fiction aimed at building a hyper-nationalist mood among supporters.

📰 The Truth Behind the Silence

In any government, silence does not always mean plotting. Intelligence and military operations require discretion, but not every quiet moment equals a secret attack.
Also, the National Security Advisor does not command the armed forces — he is an advisor, strategist, and coordinator.

⚖ Final Verdict: The Real Face of Ajit Doval

Ajit Doval is a highly respected, experienced security expert with an impressive record in intelligence and counterinsurgency.
✅ He has contributed significantly to India’s internal security, including in Punjab, Kashmir, and during major crises.
⚠ But the image of him as a shadow warrior rewriting borders and absorbing global terror groups is wildly exaggerated by supporters and online bhakt narratives.
❌ Remember: No one man shapes a nation’s destiny alone. Security is a team effort — intelligence, military, diplomacy, and political leadership all matter.

🧩 Why Does This Myth Exist?

Such myth-making feeds into a hero-worship culture where one man is credited with all victories — a pattern common in strongman politics.
It helps build nationalist sentiment, keep supporters emotionally invested, and distract from more complex political realities.

📢 Final Thought

Admiring Ajit Doval’s achievements is fair.
But let’s not fall for fantasies that paint him as an all-powerful figure rewriting maps with silence alone.
True security lies not in silence or drama — but in smart strategy, robust institutions, and collective national strength.

Comments

comments