India Wins on the Battlefield, But Why Is It Losing the Global Narrative?

In a world driven by visuals, emotion, and media influence, victories on the battlefield no longer guarantee victories in the minds of the global audience. This was starkly evident in a recent interview on Sky News, where renowned journalist Yalda Hakim spoke with Indian High Commissioner to the UK, Vikram Doraiswami. While India showcased decisive military success through its precision strike under Operation Sindoor, the conversation quickly shifted toward a far more pressing concern — why India, despite all evidence and strategic clarity, struggles to shape the global narrative.

🔥 Operation Sindoor – A Tactical Win, Strategically Questioned

India’s Operation Sindoor, launched after the deadly Pahalgam terrorist attack, successfully targeted cross-border terror infrastructure, taking out key Lashkar-e-Taiba operatives. The Indian military executed this strike with precision, caution, and clarity of purpose. Yet, as Doraiswami tried to explain, the world didn’t applaud the operation with the same enthusiasm.

Instead, a familiar pattern followed:

• Western headlines remained neutral or skeptical.
• “Escalation fears” became the dominant media theme.
• India’s justification for a counter-terror strike was diluted into geopolitical anxiety.

When the High Commissioner showed a photo of Pakistani Army officers attending the funeral of the terrorists killed by India — a clear proof of state complicity — it still failed to spark global outrage or support. Why?

🧠 Why the West Doesn’t “Get” India’s Narrative

There are deep-rooted issues behind the West’s hesitancy to back India’s stance unequivocally:

1. Colonial Hangover & Soft Bigotry

Despite being the world’s largest democracy, India is often still viewed through an Orientalist lens. There’s a subtle Western arrogance that assumes India can’t act without overreacting. Every Indian military action is questioned for “proportionality,” while Western strikes in Iraq or Afghanistan are celebrated as bold counterterrorism efforts.

2. Pakistan’s Mastery of Playing the Victim

For decades, Pakistan has mastered the art of “crying wolf.” Even when it harbors and breeds terrorism, it plays the peace-seeking, victimized nuclear state. Western journalists, often unfamiliar with subcontinental history, buy into the emotional narrative Pakistan offers — complete with images of children, mosques, and mourning families — while ignoring the terror factories behind them.

3. Media Influence & Narratives

The West’s mainstream media often relies on freelance journalists and agencies embedded in volatile areas, many of whom operate within Pakistan’s narrative control. Moreover, India has traditionally failed to invest in global English-language media that can match Al Jazeera, BBC, or CNN in influence.

4. India’s Poor PR Strategy

India has satellites in space, but almost no English-language international media channel with global influence. There’s no “Indian CNN” presenting factual, emotionally compelling counter-narratives. The government relies too much on bureaucratic statements and official briefings — which are tone-deaf in the age of social media and bite-sized news.

5. Reluctance to Name the Enemy

The West responds to boldness and clarity. When the US names ISIS or Al-Qaeda without mincing words, the global audience gets it. India often softens its stance diplomatically, using vague terms like “cross-border actors” or “non-state elements,” instead of stating clearly: “The Pakistani Army backs terrorism.”

🧩 What Can India Do to Win the Narrative War?

If India wants to win both militarily and ideologically, some fundamental changes are needed:

✅ 1. Invest in Media Diplomacy

India must create and back independent global media houses in English and regional languages that tell India’s story unapologetically. Real-time news, documentaries, and talk shows can challenge disinformation with facts and emotion.

✅ 2. Empower Indian Diplomats with Data and Digital Tools

Ambassadors should be equipped with visuals, satellite data, leaked intelligence, and emotional stories from victims of Pakistani-sponsored terrorism. A single tweet with proof can have more impact than a 10-page press release.

✅ 3. Call Out Hypocrisy Boldly

India must start calling out the West’s double standards. Why is Russia condemned for Ukraine, but Pakistan celebrated despite hosting terrorists? Why are drone strikes fine in Syria but not in PoK? The hypocrisy must be exposed with calm confidence.

✅ 4. Use Influencers & Diaspora Smartly

India has a massive diaspora and influential voices worldwide — doctors, engineers, YouTubers, filmmakers. These voices can humanize the impact of terrorism in India and amplify India’s side of the story.

✅ 5. Show, Don’t Just Tell

Show visuals of the terrorists’ funerals attended by Pakistan’s army. Show the victims’ families. Show blood-stained schoolbags. Let the world see what Indians see. Let emotion drive truth, because facts alone don’t sway narratives anymore.

🔍 Final Thought: The Battlefield Is Only Half the War

In the age of perception, every bullet fired is also a headline. Every dead terrorist is a potential PR win — or loss. While India has the strength to eliminate threats militarily, the real war is for the global conscience. And right now, that battle is far from over.

To win it, India must stop whispering its truth — and start shouting it through every mic, every screen, every corner of the digital world.

🇮🇳 Truth needs a voice louder than lies. It’s time India builds a megaphone.

Comments

comments