There is a scene that plays every morning in Mumbai like a ritual.

9:10 AM. Dombivli fast suburban train. VT (CST) route.

A train arrives.
A crowd attacks it.
People hang outside like human flags.
Bags are crushed. Shirts are torn.
Someone’s foot is on someone else’s shoe.
Someone’s elbow is inside someone else’s ribs.

And then… the train leaves.

And the most shocking part?

This happens every day… and not many accidents are reported.

Not because it’s safe.
But because Mumbai has mastered something the world finds impossible:

The art of surviving chaos without questioning it.

India is Different… and That’s Not Always a Compliment

When Indians go abroad, many experience a strange fear.

No crowd.
No pushing.
No stampede energy.

It feels… unnatural.

Because our brain is conditioned to believe:

“If people are not fighting to enter something, maybe it’s not important.”

This is not just about trains.

This is a national psychological setting.

In India, crowd is not a problem.
Crowd is culture.

And sadly, crowd is also proof of our failure.

Who Are These People?

Let’s be honest.

These are not tourists.
These are not people on a picnic.

These are the working class.
The salaried class.
The backbone.

These are taxpayers.

People who wake up at 6 AM, travel like animals, work like machines, return home exhausted, and repeat.

And we have normalized treating them like disposable cargo.

We treat them as if they should be grateful that the train even stops.

The Biggest Lie: “More Trains Will Solve It”

Many people say:
“Bring more trains. Add more coaches. Increase frequency.”

But here’s the uncomfortable truth:

Even metro trains run every 5–10 minutes… and people still push like it’s a war.

Because the problem is not just supply.

The problem is:

• population pressure
• lack of civic sense
• lack of discipline
• and worst of all… lack of consequences

In India, the crowd behaves badly because the crowd knows one thing:

“Nobody will stop us.”

Why Doesn’t This Happen in Other Countries?

Because in many countries:

• People stand in line
• Doors open only when passengers exit
• People fear rules
• People fear fines
• People fear social shame

In India?

You can break a rule and still feel proud.

In fact, if you jump the line, some will call you “smart”.

That’s the difference.

Other countries train citizens to respect society.

India trains citizens to outsmart society.

The Harsh Reality: We Don’t Need More Trains… We Need Tameez

This is where the truth hurts.

People don’t behave like this because they enjoy pushing.

They behave like this because they’ve accepted one mindset:

“If I don’t push, I will be left behind.”

So the system creates selfishness.

And selfishness becomes survival.

And survival becomes habit.

And habit becomes culture.

Then culture becomes “normal”.

That is the real tragedy.

The “Danda Policy” Joke… That Isn’t Really a Joke

Many frustrated Indians say:

“Give them a danda. Lathi charge them once. Then they will learn.”

Sounds harsh, but why does this thought even come?

Because deep down, people have realized:

In India, gentle requests don’t work.

Only consequences work.

A society that doesn’t fear consequences becomes a jungle.

And jungles don’t need education.
They need control.

That’s why even educated people start dreaming of extreme solutions.

Not because they love violence…

But because they’ve lost faith in discipline.

This Was the Same 20 Years Ago… That’s the Real Horror

Someone said:

“It was like this 20 years ago when I travelled. It is still the same.”

That is the most painful line in this whole discussion.

Because it means:

India is developing… but not evolving.

We built metro lines.
We built highways.
We built apps.
We built billion-dollar companies.

But we couldn’t build one simple thing:

basic human order.

The Irony: “We Are the 4th Largest Economy”

This is where India becomes a walking contradiction.

We proudly announce GDP rankings like trophies.

But GDP doesn’t show dignity.

GDP doesn’t show comfort.

GDP doesn’t show quality of life.

GDP doesn’t show whether a man can travel to work without risking death.

So yes, India may be the 4th largest economy…

But if the daily experience of citizens looks like this, then one question becomes unavoidable:

Are we truly rich… or just numerically large?

India is like a huge family with a big salary…

but still living in one small room.

Why Do We Accept This?

Because Indians have a dangerous superpower:

We adjust.

We adjust to potholes.
We adjust to corruption.
We adjust to broken systems.
We adjust to overcrowding.
We adjust to poor services.

We don’t protest.
We don’t demand.

We just say:

“Chalta hai.”

And the government loves that.

Because a citizen who adjusts is the easiest citizen to manage.

The Most Shameful Part: This Is the Service After Paying Taxes

Tax is supposed to buy you dignity.

Tax is supposed to buy you safety.

Tax is supposed to buy you a system.

But in India, taxpayers often feel like:

“We pay like a developed nation, but we live like a neglected colony.”

And this daily local train madness proves it.

It’s not a transport problem anymore.

It is a governance problem.

So Do We Really Have a Choice?

Yes.

But not the kind of choice people want.

You cannot magically fix Mumbai locals overnight.

But you can choose what kind of India you want to build.

Because every broken system survives only because citizens accept it.

What Should We Do? The Real Solutions (Not Emotional Ones)

1. Civic Sense Must Become a School Subject

Not one chapter.
Not one lecture.

A full subject.

Children must learn:

• public behavior
• queue discipline
• hygiene
• basic rules of public spaces
• respecting women, elders, and workers

India teaches trigonometry to kids who will never use it…

but doesn’t teach basic public discipline which they will use every day.

That’s madness.

2. Population Control Must Be Discussed Without Fear

This topic is treated like a taboo.

But overcrowding is not a “Mumbai problem”.

It is a national reality.

Every system collapses when demand grows faster than planning.

No number of trains can defeat uncontrolled population growth.

We must stop being politically correct and start being logically correct.

3. Strict Fines and Enforcement

No danda required.

Just strict enforcement:

• heavy fines for pushing into trains
• penalties for blocking doors
• monitoring with cameras
• police accountability

In India, rules exist.

But enforcement is optional.

That’s why chaos is permanent.

4. Offices Must Shift to Staggered Work Timings

Mumbai’s biggest enemy is not the crowd.

It is the same crowd arriving at the same time.

If offices stagger work hours, 9 AM pressure reduces drastically.

Corporate India must stop acting like every employee is a factory worker.

5. Promote Walkable Cities

India doesn’t need only metros.

India needs footpaths.

Real footpaths.

Safe footpaths.

Because in India, walking is treated like punishment.

If cities were walkable, many short-distance commuters would not overload trains.

The Bigger Question: What Kind of Progress is This?

A country is not “developed” when it has billionaires.

A country is developed when:

• its public transport is safe
• its citizens respect each other
• its government respects taxpayers
• its systems function without citizens fighting like gladiators

The Mumbai local crowd is not just a railway issue.

It is a mirror.

A mirror showing that India is racing ahead economically…

while socially still crawling.

Final Thought: We Are Not Poor. We Are Unmanaged.

Mumbai locals prove one thing clearly:

Indians are not weak.
Indians are not lazy.
Indians are not incapable.

Indians are resilient beyond imagination.

But the tragedy is…

We are forced to use resilience where we should have been using dignity.

A nation should not demand daily suffering as proof of patriotism.

If a citizen is risking life just to reach office…

then the system is not serving the people.

The people are sacrificing themselves to keep the system running.

And that is not development.

That is exploitation with a national anthem playing in the background.

So what is true? Is India a global superpower or a struggling country?

The answer is:

India is a superpower on paper… and a survival game on the streets.

And that contradiction is the real irony of the present era.

The world sees India’s GDP.

But Indians live India’s reality.

And Mumbai local at 9:10 AM is the loudest proof.

If we want change, we must stop calling this “spirit of Mumbai” and start calling it what it truly is:

A daily reminder that taxpayers deserve better than being treated like livestock.

Comments

comments